Expert Advice: 5 Myths About Wedding Cake Pops

Wedding Cake Pops | Tampa Bay Baker Sweetly Dipped Confections

Lily Pulitzer Inspired Wedding Cake Pops | Tampa Wedding Cake Pop Baker Sweetly Dipped Confections

All Cake Pops Are the Same

There are two different kinds of cake pops. In one version, a full cake is baked, mixed with frosting, then hand-rolled into a ball. The resulting texture is akin to a truffle. In the other version, the cake pop is baked right from the start using a cake pop machine. The resulting texture is light and fluffy, just like a cake or cupcake.

One way isn’t “better” than the other; it comes down to your personal preference. While I prefer a light and fluffy cake pop, someone else may very well prefer a hand-rolled, thicker cake pop. If you’re unsure what you like, schedule an appointment to taste a few flavors and discuss designs and ideas.

Cake Pops are Smaller than a Cake so They Must be Less Expensive

While basic cake pops are sometimes more cost-effective than a cake, this is typically not the case when they’re made to match a certain decor. While a cake baker has just one cake to decorate, a cake pop baker has multiple, sometimes hundreds, of cake pops to decorate, each one with it’s own specific design.

The average cake pop starts at $2 each and can typically be matched to your color scheme. On the other end, extremely detailed cake pops can go up to $5 or even $6 per pop, depending on the level of detail and products used. Cake pops with edible gold leaf, for example, have a simple, classy look, but they cost more because of the gold leaf. You can always mix and match the more expensive designs with some basic ones,helping you achieve the look you want while staying within your desired budget.

While big box stores and mega coffee shop chains may offer less expensive cake pops, they are also mass produced and often filled with preservatives so that they can sit on a shelf until sold. Our cake pops are made by hand and always made to order. Custom is always going to cost more, but the end result will always be better. As the saying goes, good cake ain’t cheap and cheap cake ain’t good.

Formal Tuxedo and Wedding Dress Cake Pops | Tampa Wedding Cake Pop Baker Sweetly Dipped Confections

Cake Pops are Less Fragile Than a Wedding Cake

If you’re tying the knot in the midst of a Florida summer, please keep in mind that your cake pops can’t stand the heat. Being outside that time of year will inevitably make a lot of confections melt. Even though the heat creates a hurdle, you can still overcome it if you take the proper precautions.

Many venues will have an indoor area; this is the ideal place to keep your sweets, especially if you’re creating a full dessert table. If your dream is to have your guests dining on their desserts outside, then make arrangements to have everything remain inside, or kept cool, until just before serving. No one wants to eat a melted, messy cake pop!

All Cake Pop Bakers Are the Same

Unfortunately, there are always people out there who may misrepresent themselves. The baking community, believe it or not, is pretty small. I have seen it happen numerous times where a relatively new baker will post photos of other people’s work and promote it as their own. The victim winds up being the client, who may not get what they were promised. A great way to avoid this is to check their references and testimonials and see if they’re part of any reputable associations (such as Marry Me Tampa Bay). The last thing you want is for your wedding cake or desserts to be known as a #cakefail.

Once you’re happy with your cake popper’s skill level, as with any vendor, customer service also plays into your overall experience. Does your vendor reply in a timely manner? Do they offer examples or sketches to make sure both your visions are on the same page? Any information you can provide (invitations, color swatches, Pinterest boards, etc.) all help to achieve the look you want!

Spring Cherry Blossom and Rustic Wedding Cake Pops | Tampa Wedding Cake Pop Baker Sweetly Dipped Confections

My Friend Is a Baker, So I’ll Just Hire Him/Her

Unless your friend has their own business and has experience with large-scale baking, I would absolutely leave this aspect to a professional. With all of the time you’ve spent planning every detail, having a trusted and vetted vendor is truly priceless. Your family member or friend may have the best of intentions, but do they have the skills necessary to execute your vision to your expectations? It comes down to knowing your strengths and the strengths of others. I make a mean cake pop, but I have no problem hiring someone else when I need a cake. Your wedding desserts, whether they be cake pops, cupcakes, a cake or a full dessert bar, should not be known and remembered for your friend’s good intentions.

Sweetly Dipped Confections Owner Brandi Matiyak Headshot Brandi Matiyak has made cake pops and chocolate dipped desserts since 2012. Before diving into the world of baking, she anchored the morning newscast for an Iowa TV station. She perfected the ins and outs of storytelling and is now applying that same passion into this new (and much tastier) creative outlet. Despite her stay in the Midwest, Brandi was born and raised right here in the Bay area and is extremely happy to be home!


Marry Me Tampa Bay editor, Anna Coats, created Marry Me Tampa Bay in 2012 to showcase the area's best local weddings and vendors. She has been featured as a wedding expert on the national talkshow Daytime, Fox13, ABC Action News, Great Day Tampa Bay, and Bay News 9 (now Spectrum).

NOVA 535

NOVA 535

Avila Golf & Country Club


Organic Boho Modern White and Brown Rooftop Wedding Ceremony Flowers with Peach Roses, Gold Leaves, Feathers, and Ghost Chairs | Tampa Bay Wedding Florist Monarch Events | Planner and Designer UNIQUE Weddings + Events | Venue Aloft/Element Midtown | Photographer and Videographer Bonnie Newman Creative | Rentals A Chair Affair


St. Pete Beach Wedding Venue Bellwether Beach Resort Aerial View

The Vault

The Godfrey Hotel

Renaissance Tampa International Plaza

Hyatt Regency Clearwater Beach

Red Mesa Events

Lifelong Photography Studio

Creative Bride and Groom Wedding Portrait with Veil Blowing in Wind | Tampa Bay Wedding Photographer Lifelong Photography Studio

Carrie Wildes Photography

dewitt for love

Modern Dramatic Unique Asymmetrical Red Wedding Bridal Bouquet with Ranunculus Tulips Protea Roses Anemone and Amaryllis | Dewitt for Love Photography


Tampa Bay Wedding Photographer | Limelight Photography

Breezin’ Weddings

Florida Bride and Groom Romantic Portrait Under Whimsical and Lush Circular Floral Arch with Pampas Grass, White and Blush Pink Roses, Hydrangeas and Greenery, Bride in Full Length Veil | Tampa Wedding Planner Breezin' Weddings | Wedding Dress Isabel O'Neil Bridal | Wedding Hair Femme Akoi | Waterfront Wedding Venue Tampa Yacht and Country Club

Coastal Coordinating

UNIQUE Weddings & Events

Parties a la Carte

Special Moments Event Planning

Modern, Garden Inspired Wedding Decor, Blush Pink Floral Wall and White Draping, Gazebo, Outdoor Dance Floor, Long Feasting Tables. Rose Gold Chiavari Chairs, Floral Curly Willow Arches | Tampa Bay Wedding Planner Special Moments Event Planning | Tampa Bay Wedding Florist Gabro Event Services | Tampa Bay Wedding Rentals A Chair Affair

Truly Forever Bridal

Michele Renee The Studio

Elite Events Catering


Longboat Key Club

Beso Del Sol

Isla del Sol Yacht & Country Club

The Poynter Institute

The Don CeSar Hotel

Hotel Zamora

Postcard Inn

Hotel Alba


Paradise Spring | Tampa Bay Wedding Venue Private Estate


The Lake Lodge Wedding Venue | Lake Thonotosassa Tampa Area Wedding Venue

amber mcwhorter photography

Spaghetti Strap Casablanca Ivory Simple Slip Wedding Dress Bridal Gown | Light Blue Grey Groom Suit | Outdoor Bride and Groom Beach Portrait at Tampa St Pete Florida COVID Destination Elopement Beach Wedding Ceremony | Neutral White Ivory and Greenery Bridal Bouquet | Amber McWhorter Photography

Luxe Light Images

Gulf Beach Weddings

Elope Tampa Bay

Tampa Bay Wedding Elopement Planning | Elope Tampa Bay

eventfull weddings

Tampa Bay Wedding Planner EventFull Weddings

Lynn’s Catering

Amici’s Catered Cuisine

Sweetly Dipped Confections

Bella Bridesmaid


Lifelong Photography Studio | The Current | Adore Bridal Hair and Makeup

A&P Designs

Grant Hemond & Associates

Grant Hemond and Associates | Tampa Bay Wedding DJ

breezin' entertainment

St. Petersburg Wedding DJ Breezin' Entertainment

A Chair Affair

outside the box

Tampa Bay Bride and Groom Cheers in front of Champagne Wall, Greenery Boxwood Bubbly Wall Rental, Bride Holding Vibrant Jewel Toned Floral Bouquet with Bright Pink Roses, Ivory, Purple, and Blue Flowers | Florida Wedding Planner Breezin' Weddings | South Tampa Outside The Box Event Rentals